Firstly, none of this applies to most autocrosses. Protests are typically
only seen at a Divisional/National level. If you're running Regional events, you
can skip this section - they just don't happen at Regional events.
In autocross parlence, a "weenie protest" is the practice of, when you get beat,
looking for something - anything - that might be illegal on the winner's car,
with the intent of protesting that illegality in order to get the car disqualified
and your finishing position improved. A protest is "weenie" when the item being
protested is of no performance benefit whatsoever - technically illegal, but not
why you got beat.
"Weenie protests" are rare, very rare, but they DO happen. And as the language in
most SCCA Solo classes explicitly states that "any modification not expressly
allowed is forbidden", occasionally a protest committee will uphold a protest of this
type - again, it's rare (most protest committees have enough common sense to
distinguish between legitimate cheating and "weenie fishing expeditions"), but
occasionally one slips though the cracks.
This poses a problem for SM as a class. SM DOES have rules, those rules
ARE intended to be enforced, and the protest system IS the way they are
to be enforced. However, SM also is all about allowing a certain level of creativity
and freedom with areas of the rules not explicitly called out in the rulebook.
It is impossible to get every single allowed modification into the
rulebook, even though the standard SCCA practice has been "all not allowed is forbidden".
The intent is that "any ostensibly illegal modification made to allow a
legal modifiaction is OK, as long as the illegal modification is kept to a
minimum, and serves no other purpose" Given that we can't get that into the
rulebook in a manner that isn't wide open to abuse (the other kind of "rulebook lawyer")
and given that it is up to competitors to police the class, we have come up with the
following policy:
NO WEENIES
In plain English, that means "Don't protest anything that doesn't make any real
difference" and "If you act like a weenie, you're going to have a bunch of irate
competitors in your face in a big hurry"
If you seriously feel that a competitor is cheating, or interpreting a rule in a manner
that you feel is incorrect (in other words, if you feel that you have a legitimate
protest) here's what we expect you to do:
- Round up all the other competitors in the class
- Show them/explain to them the problem area on the car in question
- Let them examine the car and come to a conclusion
- If there is agreement that the item in question deserves protest,
file the protest AS A GROUP
If, after group discussion, you still feel that the item in question requires protest,
but the majority does not agree with you, you are still entitled to file
your protest. We'd prefer that you abide by the group opinion, but
reasonable people may indeed have differing opinions and you have the
right to have yours heard by a race official. For the purposes of the
class "no weenies" policy, contacting your fellow competitors and giving
them the opportunity to weigh in with their opinions before filing
an official protest satisfies your obligation.
Accordingly, we expect competitors who object to a protest to repspect the
right of someone to disagree with their opinion, and protest anyway. As
long as you were told (as a class) ahead of time and given an opportunity
to inspect the car in question and give an opinion, fair ball.
Failure to consult your fellow competitors before filing protest, however,
will be seen as sneaky and disrespectful, and should be expected to draw ire.
REMEMBER - the intent behind SM is "any ostensibly illegal modification made to allow a
legal modifiaction is OK, as long as the illegal modification is kept to a
minimum, and serves no other purpose" RESPECT THAT.
Note that "no weenies" DOES NOT mean you can ignore any rule that is
inconvenient! Any rule that was taken the time to get called out in the rulebook
is to be taken seriously! (For example, protesting an engine that is 0.001 litre
over the displacement limit is NOT a "weenie protest"!)
What you DO have is the freedom to make minor adjustments in order to get your
legal mods to fit. So if
you have to notch your headliner to get your roll bar to fit, or if you have to
cut a hole in your radiator support to get your intercooler piping to fit, or
you want to take the little plastic covers off of your rear shock towers so
you can adjust your shocks, etc. etc. etc. that's OK.
Be reasonable, be understanding, be polite, and if in any doubt, ASK FIRST
and you'll be all right.
UPDATE There is a rule coming that should greatly solve this issue. Stay tuned!
|